
Luigi’s Restaurant and Lounge in Oelwein was destroyed in a November 2016 fire.
OELWEIN – The Iowa Supreme Court has ruled against an Oelwein restaurant that was destroyed in a fire in a dispute with its insurance company.
A kitchen fire gutted Luigi’s Restaurant and Lounge on Frederick Avenue in November 2016, resulting in a total loss.
The business was insured by United Fire and Casualty, and an initial appraisal estimated the building had been valued at $242,000, based on the market value of similar properties.
But Luigi’s owner rejected the estimate and sought a second opinion. The second review, conducted by another party, came up with a $1.03 million estimate for building and fixtures based on the cost to replace, according to court records.
An Oelwein landmark is no more following a Saturday, Nov. 12, 2016, fire. The iconic Luigi’s Restaurant and Lounge, 1020 S. Frederick Ave., was destroyed by a blaze that apparently started in the kitchen. The blaze began around 3:15 p.m. while the business was open, and the flames continued to burn into the night with authorities finally tearing down the walls as the fire raged on.
A hearing between the two appraisers came up with a $502,000 loss, which was just under the $550,000 loss limit on the insurance policy.
Luigi’s took United Fire to court alleging the insurance company lowballed its offer. A jury awarded the restaurant $48,000 in actual damages for the difference between the appraisal and the policy limit. Jurors also awarded $41,000 in a bad-faith claim for expenses Luigi’s incurred and another $30,000 in punitive damages.
Live, raw video from Luigi’s Restaurant fire in Oelwein. Nov. 12, 2016. Originally posted on Periscope.
United Fire appealed the verdict, and in a ruling handed down Friday, the Iowa Supreme Court sided with the insurance company.
More Stories
What long Covid patients need to know about health insurance
What will insurance policies cover as life-threatening bomb cyclone, ‘Pineapple Express’ impacts California?
How much does term life insurance cost?